Finding a frosting recipe that’s safe for dogs doesn’t have to be complicated.
The right frosting can turn a plain dog-friendly cake into something extra special without worrying about harmful ingredients.
One of the most loved options among dog owners is the peanut butter and Greek yogurt frosting.
It’s easy to make, packed with flavor, and filled with ingredients that dogs adore.
This post may contain affiliate links. That means if you click on them and buy something, I may receive a small commission at no cost to you. Read my Disclaimer Policy to learn more.
Peanut Butter Frosting Ingredients
1/2 cup of plain, unsweetened Greek yogurt
1/2 cup of natural peanut butter (double check to make sure it’s free of xylitol, an artificial sweetener that’s toxic to dogs)
Instructions
Measure out your ingredients and add them both to a small bowl.
Mix the Greek yogurt and peanut butter until combined.
Refrigerate until needed, up to a couple of days.
The mixture will be thick but spread nicely on cakes, cupcakes, or even simple dog biscuits. Use the back of a spoon or a piping bag for a nicer look.
Tips
You can put the mixture in a plastic storage bag and cut a hole in the corner to use as a piping bag.
I recommend using a freezer bag instead of a sandwich bag as the plastic is a bit thicker on them. When I tried using a sandwich bag I ended up popping a hole in the side of the bag.
Just try to find a freezer bag that is not the expandable bottom type of bag. Those bags are difficult to cut a small hole in corner due to how the bag is designed.
There is no need to pipe this frosting onto the pupcakes; your dog doesn’t care what they look like. If they’re anything like my dogs, they don’t look at the treats, they gobble them up as fast as possible.
How Much Frosting is Safe to Use and How Often to Give it to Dogs
Always consult your veterinarian before giving your dog new foods.
When it comes to treating your dog, frosting adds a fun and celebratory touch to their snacks or special occasion cakes.
However, even when using dog-safe ingredients, moderation is key to keeping your dog healthy.
Even healthy ingredients like Greek yogurt and peanut butter can add up in calories and fat content.
Overindulgence could upset your dog’s stomach or contribute to weight gain over time.
Here are some simple tips to guide you:
- Match the Size of the Treat to Your Dog:
A small dog requires much less frosting than a larger breed. Think of it like this: the amount of frosting should stay proportional to the size of the treat. For example, a teaspoon of frosting is usually sufficient for a pupcake for small breeds, while larger dogs might handle a tablespoon. - Consider Their Daily Diet:
Dog-safe frosting should be a “sometimes treat” rather than a regular part of your pet’s diet. If your dog is already eating a calorie-dense meal that day, cut back on the frosting or the portion size of the treat. - Limit Frequency:
Keep frosted treats as an occasional reward rather than a daily habit. A good rule of thumb? Save it for special moments like birthdays, gotcha day, or just a fun, once-a-week surprise. This keeps the treat exciting while maintaining your dog’s overall health. - Start Small to Test Tolerances:
If this is your first time giving your dog frosted treats, give just a small amount to see how they respond. Dogs with sensitive stomachs may need an even lighter touch.
Remember, dogs rely on you to balance indulgence with their health.
A little dog icing goes a long way in making a treat feel special without overdoing it.
